Metromix | Metromix New York

Magnolia Bakery: User Reviews

Magnolia Bakery

401 Bleecker St. - New York
212-462-2572
No-pic-chick

Diabetic Coma
By Toni1964 from N.Y. N.Y., February 8, 2009

Overall rating:
2

Hi, I finally got to the infamous Magnolia, an adorable bakery. However after waiting in line it went fast though.. The cupcake very fresh, they don't have time to get stale. Who doesen't like frosting? Well I love it! But it was like biting into a 3 inch thick mountain of sugar and kinda tasted like mac & cheese w/ sugar? so strange,It ight have been the butter they used u could taste butter and sugar only the cake was lost, so sweet I was sick afterward!

Ambiance:
5
Food:
2
Service:
4
Value:
2
Report This Review

Crazy for Those Cupcakes Cousin
By ArlingtonBurns from Westover, November 13, 2007

Overall rating:
5

OK, I didn't believe the hype and finally broke down to stnad in line. Buttercream, sprinkles, a glass of cold milk and the mother of all cupcakes. Simply put....awesome.

Ambiance:
3
Food:
5
Service:
4
Value:
4
Report This Review

Review Summary

The following scores represent the average rating submitted by 2 users:

Overall user rating:
3 1/2
Ambiance
4
Food
3 1/2
Service
4
Value
3